3.8″
off the zone
José Caballero vs Kevin Kelly
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Dan Bellino • Challenged by NYY
Leverage: 1.17Egregiousness: 4.45
Daily Robberies
The worst MLB calls of April 12, 2026 — overturned ABS challenges ranked by leverage × call magnitude.
3.8″
worst miss
2.3″
avg miss
1.50
avg leverage
3.0″
off the zone
Gary Sánchez vs Cole Henry
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Carlos Torres • Challenged by MIL
Leverage: 1.22Egregiousness: 3.68
1.7″
off the zone
Tyrone Taylor vs Scott Barlow
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: D.J. Reyburn • Challenged by NYM
Leverage: 1.93Egregiousness: 3.33
1.8″
off the zone
Brett Baty vs Hogan Harris
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: D.J. Reyburn • Challenged by ATH
Leverage: 1.58Egregiousness: 2.89
3.8″
off the zone
Austin Slater vs Tarik Skubal
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Mike Estabrook • Challenged by MIA
Leverage: 0.76Egregiousness: 2.84
3.1″
off the zone
Jonathan Aranda vs Cam Schlittler
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Dan Bellino • Challenged by TB
Leverage: 0.89Egregiousness: 2.75
1.9″
off the zone
Drew Millas vs Brandon Woodruff
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Carlos Torres • Challenged by MIL
Leverage: 1.35Egregiousness: 2.56
1.0″
off the zone
Nick Kurtz vs Sean Manaea
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: D.J. Reyburn • Challenged by NYM
Leverage: 2.42Egregiousness: 2.50
1.6″
off the zone
Maikel Garcia vs Jordan Leasure
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Nick Mahrley • Challenged by KC
Leverage: 1.55Egregiousness: 2.49
1.1″
off the zone
Oneil Cruz vs Jameson Taillon
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Alan Porter • Challenged by CHC
Leverage: 2.15Egregiousness: 2.32
Ranked by leverage index × call magnitude. Regular-season ABS pitch challenges only. Updated daily at 6 AM ET.