4.1″
off the zone
Max Schuemann vs Sean Manaea
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Jeremie Rehak • Challenged by NYY
Leverage: 1.60Egregiousness: 6.55
Daily Attempted Robberies
The worst MLB calls of May 17, 2026 — overturned ABS challenges ranked by leverage × call magnitude.
4.1″
worst miss
1.8″
avg miss
1.32
avg leverage
2.6″
off the zone
Ryan Jeffers vs DL Hall
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Junior Valentine • Challenged by MIN
Leverage: 1.58Egregiousness: 4.09
1.7″
off the zone
Jakob Marsee vs Garrett Cleavinger
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Ramon De Jesus • Challenged by MIA
Leverage: 1.98Egregiousness: 3.31
1.2″
inside the zone
Victor Caratini vs Robert Gasser
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Junior Valentine • Challenged by MIL
Leverage: 1.52Egregiousness: 1.78
2.9″
off the zone
Steven Kwan vs Brock Burke
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: David Rackley • Challenged by CLE
Leverage: 0.45Egregiousness: 1.31
1.4″
inside the zone
Sal Stewart vs Gavin Williams
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: David Rackley • Challenged by CLE
Leverage: 0.90Egregiousness: 1.30
2.0″
off the zone
Alex Bregman vs Erick Fedde
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Chris Segal • Challenged by CHC
Leverage: 0.66Egregiousness: 1.30
1.2″
off the zone
Justin Foscue vs Cody Bolton
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Manny Gonzalez • Challenged by TEX
Leverage: 0.90Egregiousness: 1.08
0.3″
off the zone
Seiya Suzuki vs Tyler Davis
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Chris Segal • Challenged by CHC
Leverage: 2.92Egregiousness: 1.02
1.1″
inside the zone
Alex Bregman vs Sean Newcomb
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Chris Segal • Challenged by CWS
Leverage: 0.73Egregiousness: 0.78
Ranked by Robbery Score (leverage index × call magnitude). Regular-season ABS pitch challenges only. Updated daily at 6 AM ET.