3.8″
off the zone
Nolan Schanuel vs Hunter Gaddis
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Jeremie Rehak • Challenged by LAA
Leverage: 2.16Egregiousness: 8.17
Daily Robberies
The worst MLB calls of May 12, 2026 — overturned ABS challenges ranked by leverage × call magnitude.
4.2″
worst miss
2.5″
avg miss
1.62
avg leverage
2.8″
off the zone
Rhys Hoskins vs Drew Pomeranz
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Jeremie Rehak • Challenged by CLE
Leverage: 2.63Egregiousness: 7.27
2.0″
inside the zone
Jac Caglianone vs Grant Taylor
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Chris Conroy • Challenged by CWS
Leverage: 3.41Egregiousness: 6.79
4.2″
off the zone
Max Schuemann vs Josh Walker
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Hunter Wendelstedt • Challenged by NYY
Leverage: 0.58Egregiousness: 2.43
2.0″
off the zone
Matt McLain vs Miles Mikolas
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Mike Muchlinski • Challenged by CIN
Leverage: 1.11Egregiousness: 2.21
2.8″
off the zone
Davis Schneider vs Shane McClanahan
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Chris Segal • Challenged by TOR
Leverage: 0.68Egregiousness: 1.88
3.7″
off the zone
Dillon Dingler vs Austin Warren
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Stu Scheurwater • Challenged by DET
Leverage: 0.47Egregiousness: 1.72
1.0″
inside the zone
Colt Keith vs Freddy Peralta
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Stu Scheurwater • Challenged by NYM
Leverage: 1.71Egregiousness: 1.71
1.1″
inside the zone
Sam Antonacci vs Luinder Avila
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Chris Conroy • Challenged by KC
Leverage: 1.55Egregiousness: 1.69
Ranked by leverage index × call magnitude. Regular-season ABS pitch challenges only. Updated daily at 6 AM ET.