0.8″
off the zone
Eugenio Suárez vs Javier Assad
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Sean Barber • Challenged by CIN
Leverage: 4.40Egregiousness: 3.74
Daily Attempted Robberies
The worst MLB calls of September 18, 2026 — overturned ABS challenges ranked by leverage × call magnitude.
2.9″
worst miss
1.5″
avg miss
2.11
avg leverage
0.9″
off the zone
Coby Mayo vs DL Hall
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Roberto Ortiz • Challenged by BAL
Leverage: 3.54Egregiousness: 3.19
0.7″
inside the zone
TJ Rumfield vs José A. Ferrer
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Mike Estabrook • Challenged by SEA
Leverage: 3.59Egregiousness: 2.54
1.5″
inside the zone
Xavier Edwards vs Nick Pivetta
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Marvin Hudson • Challenged by SD
Leverage: 1.66Egregiousness: 2.44
1.9″
inside the zone
Eduardo Valencia vs Sean Newcomb
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Carlos Torres • Challenged by CWS
Leverage: 1.17Egregiousness: 2.22
2.7″
off the zone
Spencer Horwitz vs Nate Pearson
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Bill Miller • Challenged by PIT
Leverage: 0.77Egregiousness: 2.05
0.9″
inside the zone
Elly De La Cruz vs Clay Holmes
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Sean Barber • Challenged by CHC
Leverage: 2.10Egregiousness: 1.94
1.5″
inside the zone
Will Smith vs Cesar Perdomo
Called Ball → overturned to Strike
HP Umpire: Louie Krupa • Challenged by SF
Leverage: 1.17Egregiousness: 1.73
2.9″
off the zone
Kyle Karros vs Bryan Woo
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Mike Estabrook • Challenged by COL
Leverage: 0.57Egregiousness: 1.65
0.7″
off the zone
Lawrence Butler vs Joey Cantillo
Called Strike → overturned to Ball
HP Umpire: Junior Valentine • Challenged by ATH
Leverage: 2.15Egregiousness: 1.51
Ranked by Robbery Score (leverage index × call magnitude). Regular-season ABS pitch challenges only. Updated daily at 6 AM ET.