Daily Attempted Robberies

The worst MLB calls of September 19, 2026 — overturned ABS challenges ranked by leverage × call magnitude.

2.8″
worst miss
1.2″
avg miss
2.36
avg leverage
1.1″
inside the zone
#1

BOS @ TB

Bot 9th • 0-1 • 1-1

Chandler Simpson vs Garrett Whitlock

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Jeremie Rehak • Challenged by BOS

Leverage: 4.57Egregiousness: 4.97
1.0″
inside the zone
#2

SEA @ COL

Bot 7th • 3-1 • 3-3

Hunter Goodman vs Cooper Criswell

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Malachi Moore • Challenged by SEA

Leverage: 3.95Egregiousness: 3.82
1.2″
inside the zone
#3

DET @ CWS

Top 5th • 1-2 • 0-1

John Peck vs Sean Burke

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Mark Wegner • Challenged by CWS

Leverage: 3.15Egregiousness: 3.68
0.6″
inside the zone
#4

NYY @ AZ

Bot 9th • 0-1 • 3-3

Jordan Lawlar vs Michael Fulmer

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Alex Tosi • Challenged by NYY

Leverage: 4.72Egregiousness: 2.91
2.8″
off the zone
#5

NYY @ AZ

Bot 1st • 1-0 • 0-0

Gabriel Moreno vs Cam Schlittler

Called Strike → overturned to Ball

HP Umpire: Alex Tosi • Challenged by AZ

Leverage: 0.81Egregiousness: 2.28
1.8″
off the zone
#6

CHC @ CIN

Top 3rd • 3-2 • 1-0

Alex Bregman vs Nick Lodolo

Called Strike → overturned to Ball

HP Umpire: John Libka • Challenged by CHC

Leverage: 1.17Egregiousness: 2.06
1.1″
inside the zone
#7

MIL @ BAL

Bot 8th • 3-3 • 1-0

Coby Mayo vs Abner Uribe

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Alex MacKay • Challenged by MIL

Leverage: 1.29Egregiousness: 1.35
1.5″
off the zone
#8

SF @ LAD

Bot 5th • 2-0 • 4-6

Tommy Edman vs Philip Abner

Called Strike → overturned to Ball

HP Umpire: John Tumpane • Challenged by LAD

Leverage: 0.81Egregiousness: 1.20
0.8″
inside the zone
#9

ATL @ HOU

Bot 6th • 0-1 • 1-2

Daulton Varsho vs Grant Holmes

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Nic Lentz • Challenged by ATL

Leverage: 1.34Egregiousness: 1.05
0.6″
inside the zone
#10

MIA @ SD

Bot 5th • 0-2 • 5-5

Luis Campusano vs Eury Pérez

Called Ball → overturned to Strike

HP Umpire: Tripp Gibson • Challenged by MIA

Leverage: 1.80Egregiousness: 1.00

Ranked by Robbery Score (leverage index × call magnitude). Regular-season ABS pitch challenges only. Updated daily at 6 AM ET.