Philadelphia Phillies

PHI — ABS Challenge Profile

Games

Total Challenges

Overturned

Confirmed

Overturn Rate

52.6%

Per Game

1.9

Batter Challenges

36 (50%)

Catcher Challenges

42 (54.8%)

Top Challengers

Player	Type	Challenges	Overturned	Confirmed	Overturn Rate
J.T. Realmuto	Catcher	31	19	12	61.3%
Rafael Marchán	Catcher	11	5	6	45.5%
Kyle Schwarber	Batter	11	7	4	63.6%
Justin Crawford	Batter	5	1	4	20%
Adolis García	Batter	4	2	2	50%
Bryce Harper	Batter	3	1	2	33.3%
Alec Bohm	Batter	3	2	1	66.7%
Trea Turner	Batter	3	1	2	33.3%
Bryson Stott	Batter	2	1	1	50%
Felix Reyes	Batter	1	0	1	0%
Garrett Stubbs	Catcher	1	0	1	0%
Dylan Moore	Batter	1	1	0	100%
Edmundo Sosa	Batter	1	1	0	100%
Drew Millas	Catcher	1	0	1	0%

Umpire Matchups

Umpire	Games	Challenges	Overturned	Overturn Rate
Lance Barrett	1	6	5	83.3%
Edwin Moscoso	2	5	2	40%
D.J. Reyburn	2	5	3	60%
John Bacon	2	4	2	50%
Vic Carapazza	2	4	2	50%
Mike Muchlinski	1	4	3	75%
Adam Hamari	1	4	3	75%
Malachi Moore	1	3	1	33.3%
Nate Tomlinson	2	3	1	33.3%
Charlie Ramos	1	3	1	33.3%

Games with Challenges

Date	Opponent	Score	HP Umpire	Challenges	Overturned
2026-05-10	vs COL	6–0	Edwin Moscoso	2	0
2026-05-09	vs COL	9–3	John Bacon	2	2
2026-05-08	vs COL	7–9	Vic Carapazza	2	1
2026-05-07	vs ATH	1–12	Alfonso Márquez	2	2
2026-05-06	vs ATH	6–3	Lance Barrett	6	5
2026-05-05	vs ATH	9–1	Malachi Moore	3	1
2026-05-04	@ MIA	1–0	Bruce Dreckman	1	0
2026-05-03	@ MIA	7–2	Nate Tomlinson	2	0
2026-05-01	@ MIA	6–5	Mark Wegner	1	0
2026-04-30	vs SF	6–5	David Rackley	2	1
2026-04-30	vs SF	3–2	Charlie Ramos	3	1
2026-04-28	vs SF	7–0	Nestor Ceja	2	1
2026-04-26	@ ATL	2–6	Mike Muchlinski	4	3
2026-04-25	@ ATL	8–5	Emil Jimenez	1	0
2026-04-24	@ ATL	3–5	Dexter Kelley	1	0
2026-04-23	@ CHC	7–8	Hunter Wendelstedt	3	2
2026-04-22	@ CHC	2–7	John Bacon	2	0
2026-04-21	@ CHC	4–7	Vic Carapazza	2	1
2026-04-20	@ CHC	1–5	Edwin Moscoso	3	2
2026-04-19	vs ATL	2–4	D.J. Reyburn	1	1
2026-04-18	vs ATL	1–3	James Hoye	1	0
2026-04-17	vs ATL	0–9	John Libka	1	0
2026-04-15	vs CHC	2–11	Bruce Dreckman	1	0
2026-04-14	vs CHC	4–10	Mark Wegner	1	0
2026-04-13	vs CHC	13–7	Nate Tomlinson	1	1
2026-04-12	vs AZ	3–4	Dan Merzel	3	1
2026-04-11	vs AZ	4–3	Brock Ballou	1	1
2026-04-10	vs AZ	4–5	Quinn Wolcott	1	0
2026-04-08	@ SF	0–5	Todd Tichenor	2	2
2026-04-06	@ SF	6–4	Adam Hamari	4	3
2026-04-05	@ COL	1–4	Andy Fletcher	2	2
2026-04-04	@ COL	2–1	Alex Tosi	2	1
2026-04-03	@ COL	10–1	Jansen Visconti	1	1
2026-04-01	vs WSH	6–5	Tripp Gibson	2	0
2026-03-31	vs WSH	3–2	Marvin Hudson	1	1
2026-03-30	vs WSH	2–13	Nick Mahrley	2	1
2026-03-29	vs TEX	3–8	Sean Barber	2	2
2026-03-28	vs TEX	4–5	D.J. Reyburn	4	2
2026-03-26	vs TEX	5–3	James Hoye	1	0

All Challenges

2026-05-10vs COLBot 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Adolis García vs Tomoyuki Sugano — HP: Edwin Moscoso

2026-05-10vs COLTop 3ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Edwin Moscoso

2026-05-09vs COLTop 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Chase Shugart — HP: John Bacon

2026-05-09vs COLBot 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Justin Crawford vs Tanner Gordon — HP: John Bacon

2026-05-08vs COLTop 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs José Alvarado — HP: Vic Carapazza

2026-05-08vs COLTop 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs José Alvarado — HP: Vic Carapazza

2026-05-07vs ATHTop 5OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Rafael Marchán vs Tanner Banks — HP: Alfonso Márquez

2026-05-07vs ATHTop 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Rafael Marchán vs Andrew Painter — HP: Alfonso Márquez

2026-05-06vs ATHTop 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Brad Keller — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-06vs ATHBot 8OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Jack Perkins — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-06vs ATHBot 5ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kyle Schwarber vs Jeffrey Springs — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-06vs ATHTop 4OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Zack Wheeler — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-06vs ATHTop 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Zack Wheeler — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-06vs ATHBot 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Adolis García vs Jeffrey Springs — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-05vs ATHTop 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Jhoan Duran — HP: Malachi Moore

2026-05-05vs ATHTop 6ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Malachi Moore

2026-05-05vs ATHBot 2OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Luis Severino — HP: Malachi Moore

2026-05-04vs MIATop 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Justin Crawford vs Calvin Faucher — HP: Bruce Dreckman

2026-05-03vs MIATop 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Felix Reyes vs Tyler Phillips — HP: Nate Tomlinson

2026-05-03vs MIABot 2ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Jesús Luzardo — HP: Nate Tomlinson

2026-05-01vs MIABot 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Brad Keller — HP: Mark Wegner

2026-04-30vs SFBot 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Bryce Harper vs Ryan Borucki — HP: David Rackley

2026-04-30vs SFTop 1ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Garrett Stubbs vs Tim Mayza — HP: David Rackley

2026-04-30vs SFTop 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Orion Kerkering — HP: Charlie Ramos

2026-04-30vs SFTop 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Rafael Marchán vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Charlie Ramos

2026-04-30vs SFTop 5ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Charlie Ramos

2026-04-28vs SFBot 4ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Bryson Stott vs Tyler Mahle — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-04-28vs SFBot 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Alec Bohm vs Tyler Mahle — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-04-26vs ATLTop 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Dylan Moore vs Chris Sale — HP: Mike Muchlinski

2026-04-26vs ATLBot 4ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Aaron Nola — HP: Mike Muchlinski

2026-04-26vs ATLTop 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Chris Sale — HP: Mike Muchlinski

2026-04-26vs ATLTop 2OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Alec Bohm vs Chris Sale — HP: Mike Muchlinski

2026-04-25vs ATLBot 4ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Zack Wheeler — HP: Emil Jimenez

2026-04-24vs ATLTop 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Bryce Harper vs Grant Holmes — HP: Dexter Kelley

2026-04-23vs CHCTop 9OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Trea Turner vs Riley Martin — HP: Hunter Wendelstedt

2026-04-23vs CHCTop 6ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kyle Schwarber vs Edward Cabrera — HP: Hunter Wendelstedt

2026-04-23vs CHCBot 2OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Rafael Marchán vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Hunter Wendelstedt

2026-04-22vs CHCTop 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Bryce Harper vs Matthew Boyd — HP: John Bacon

2026-04-22vs CHCBot 2ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Taijuan Walker — HP: John Bacon

2026-04-21vs CHCTop 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Trea Turner vs Riley Martin — HP: Vic Carapazza

2026-04-21vs CHCTop 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Edmundo Sosa vs Shota Imanaga — HP: Vic Carapazza

2026-04-20vs CHCBot 7ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Chase Shugart — HP: Edwin Moscoso

2026-04-20vs CHCBot 6OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Chase Shugart — HP: Edwin Moscoso

2026-04-20vs CHCBot 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Aaron Nola — HP: Edwin Moscoso

2026-04-19vs ATLTop 2OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Andrew Painter — HP: D.J. Reyburn

2026-04-18vs ATLTop 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Tanner Banks — HP: James Hoye

2026-04-17vs ATLBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Alec Bohm vs José Suarez — HP: John Libka

2026-04-15vs CHCTop 6ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Jesús Luzardo — HP: Bruce Dreckman

2026-04-14vs CHCBot 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Trea Turner vs Colin Rea — HP: Mark Wegner

2026-04-13vs CHCTop 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Seth Johnson — HP: Nate Tomlinson

2026-04-12vs AZBot 9ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Justin Crawford vs Paul Sewald — HP: Dan Merzel

2026-04-12vs AZTop 4ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Andrew Painter — HP: Dan Merzel

2026-04-12vs AZTop 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Andrew Painter — HP: Dan Merzel

2026-04-11vs AZBot 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Bryson Stott vs Brandon Pfaadt — HP: Brock Ballou

2026-04-10vs AZBot 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kyle Schwarber vs Juan Morillo — HP: Quinn Wolcott

2026-04-08vs SFBot 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jonathan Bowlan — HP: Todd Tichenor

2026-04-08vs SFBot 6OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Aaron Nola — HP: Todd Tichenor

2026-04-06vs SFBot 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Brad Keller — HP: Adam Hamari

2026-04-06vs SFTop 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Justin Crawford vs Caleb Kilian — HP: Adam Hamari

2026-04-06vs SFTop 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Ryan Borucki — HP: Adam Hamari

2026-04-06vs SFBot 6OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jonathan Bowlan — HP: Adam Hamari

2026-04-05vs COLTop 9OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Rafael Marchán vs Victor Vodnik — HP: Andy Fletcher

2026-04-05vs COLBot 4OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Taijuan Walker — HP: Andy Fletcher

2026-04-04vs COLBot 6OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jesús Luzardo — HP: Alex Tosi

2026-04-04vs COLTop 2ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jimmy Herget — HP: Alex Tosi

2026-04-03vs COLTop 6OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Adolis García vs Valente Bellozo — HP: Jansen Visconti

2026-04-01vs WSHTop 2ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Cristopher Sánchez — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-04-01vs WSHBot 1ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Drew Millas vs Cade Cavalli — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-03-31vs WSHBot 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Zack Littell — HP: Marvin Hudson

2026-03-28vs TEXBot 10ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kyle Schwarber vs Tyler Alexander — HP: D.J. Reyburn

2026-03-28vs TEXTop 10OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jhoan Duran — HP: D.J. Reyburn

2026-03-28vs TEXTop 10OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jhoan Duran — HP: D.J. Reyburn

2026-03-28vs TEXBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Justin Crawford vs Jakob Junis — HP: D.J. Reyburn

2026-03-30vs WSHBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Adolis García vs Brad Lord — HP: Nick Mahrley

2026-03-30vs WSHBot 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Brad Lord — HP: Nick Mahrley

2026-03-29vs TEXBot 8OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kyle Schwarber vs Carter Baumler — HP: Sean Barber

2026-03-29vs TEXTop 2OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

J.T. Realmuto vs Jesús Luzardo — HP: Sean Barber

2026-03-26vs TEXTop 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

J.T. Realmuto vs Zach Pop — HP: James Hoye