Toronto Blue Jays

TOR — ABS Challenge Profile

Games

Total Challenges

Overturned

Confirmed

Overturn Rate

51.1%

Per Game

2.35

Batter Challenges

52 (51.9%)

Catcher Challenges

42 (50%)

Top Challengers

Player	Type	Challenges	Overturned	Confirmed	Overturn Rate
Brandon Valenzuela	Catcher	28	15	13	53.6%
Tyler Heineman	Catcher	14	7	7	50%
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.	Batter	10	5	5	50%
Jesús Sánchez	Batter	8	3	5	37.5%
Davis Schneider	Batter	8	6	2	75%
Andrés Giménez	Batter	5	1	4	20%
Ernie Clement	Batter	4	3	1	75%
Kazuma Okamoto	Batter	4	1	3	25%
Myles Straw	Batter	3	2	1	66.7%
George Springer	Batter	2	2	0	100%
Daulton Varsho	Batter	1	1	0	100%
Angel Martínez	Batter	1	1	0	100%
Nolan Arenado	Batter	1	0	1	0%
Adrian Del Castillo	Batter	1	1	0	100%
Brett Sullivan	Catcher	1	0	1	0%

Umpire Matchups

Umpire	Games	Challenges	Overturned	Overturn Rate
Tom Hanahan	2	8	5	62.5%
Brian O'Nora	1	6	3	50%
Manny Gonzalez	2	5	2	40%
Marvin Hudson	2	5	4	80%
Ramon De Jesus	1	5	3	60%
Paul Clemons	1	5	4	80%
Nestor Ceja	2	4	4	100%
Chris Guccione	2	4	1	25%
David Rackley	2	4	1	25%
Quinn Wolcott	1	4	2	50%

Games with Challenges

Date	Opponent	Score	HP Umpire	Challenges	Overturned
2026-05-10	vs LAA	1–6	Lance Barrett	1	0
2026-05-08	vs LAA	2–0	Mike Estabrook	1	1
2026-05-06	@ TB	0–3	Nestor Ceja	1	1
2026-05-05	@ TB	3–4	Chris Guccione	3	1
2026-05-04	@ TB	1–5	David Rackley	1	1
2026-05-03	@ MIN	3–4	Scott Barry	3	1
2026-05-02	@ MIN	11–4	Tom Hanahan	4	2
2026-05-01	@ MIN	7–3	Jacob Metz	1	0
2026-04-30	@ MIN	1–7	Manny Gonzalez	1	0
2026-04-29	vs BOS	8–1	James Jean	3	3
2026-04-28	vs BOS	3–0	Brennan Miller	1	0
2026-04-27	vs BOS	0–5	Marvin Hudson	4	3
2026-04-26	vs CLE	4–2	Ramon De Jesus	5	3
2026-04-25	vs CLE	5–3	Quinn Wolcott	4	2
2026-04-24	vs CLE	6–8	Paul Clemons	5	4
2026-04-22	@ LAA	3–7	Chad Whitson	3	1
2026-04-21	@ LAA	4–2	Chad Fairchild	2	1
2026-04-20	@ LAA	5–2	Brian Walsh	4	3
2026-04-19	@ AZ	10–4	Roberto Ortiz	3	0
2026-04-18	@ AZ	2–6	Jim Wolf	2	2
2026-04-16	@ MIL	1–2	Nestor Ceja	3	3
2026-04-15	@ MIL	1–2	Chris Guccione	1	0
2026-04-14	@ MIL	9–7	David Rackley	3	0
2026-04-11	vs MIN	4–7	Tom Hanahan	4	3
2026-04-10	vs MIN	10–4	Manny Gonzalez	4	2
2026-04-08	vs LAD	4–3	Dan Bellino	2	1
2026-04-07	vs LAD	1–4	Dan Merzel	2	2
2026-04-06	vs LAD	2–14	Shane Livensparger	3	0
2026-04-05	@ CWS	0–3	Jordan Baker	1	0
2026-04-04	@ CWS	3–6	Junior Valentine	1	1
2026-04-03	@ CWS	4–5	Stu Scheurwater	1	0
2026-04-01	vs COL	1–2	Brian O'Nora	6	3
2026-03-31	vs COL	5–1	Laz Diaz	3	0
2026-03-30	vs COL	5–14	Erich Bacchus	2	0
2026-03-29	vs ATH	5–2	Ryan Blakney	1	1
2026-03-28	vs ATH	8–7	Tripp Gibson	4	2
2026-03-27	vs ATH	3–2	Marvin Hudson	1	1

All Challenges

2026-05-10vs LAABot 9ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Jesús Sánchez vs Ryan Zeferjahn — HP: Lance Barrett

2026-05-08vs LAABot 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Reid Detmers — HP: Mike Estabrook

2026-05-06vs TBTop 2OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Ernie Clement vs Shane McClanahan — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-05-05vs TBBot 3ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Chris Guccione

2026-05-05vs TBBot 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Chris Guccione

2026-05-05vs TBBot 3ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Chris Guccione

2026-05-04vs TBTop 8OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Jesús Sánchez vs Cole Sulser — HP: David Rackley

2026-05-03vs MINTop 9ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Justin Topa — HP: Scott Barry

2026-05-03vs MINBot 5ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Braydon Fisher — HP: Scott Barry

2026-05-03vs MINTop 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Jesús Sánchez vs Andrew Morris — HP: Scott Barry

2026-05-02vs MINBot 6ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Dylan Cease — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-05-02vs MINTop 4OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Myles Straw vs Connor Prielipp — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-05-02vs MINTop 2OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Connor Prielipp — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-05-02vs MINTop 2ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Davis Schneider vs Connor Prielipp — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-05-01vs MINBot 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Tyler Rogers — HP: Jacob Metz

2026-04-30vs MINBot 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Mason Fluharty — HP: Manny Gonzalez

2026-04-29vs BOSTop 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Spencer Miles — HP: James Jean

2026-04-29vs BOSTop 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Tommy Nance — HP: James Jean

2026-04-29vs BOSTop 2OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Eric Lauer — HP: James Jean

2026-04-28vs BOSBot 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kazuma Okamoto vs Payton Tolle — HP: Brennan Miller

2026-04-27vs BOSBot 6OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Ranger Suarez — HP: Marvin Hudson

2026-04-27vs BOSBot 4ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Ranger Suarez — HP: Marvin Hudson

2026-04-27vs BOSTop 4OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Dylan Cease — HP: Marvin Hudson

2026-04-27vs BOSBot 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Myles Straw vs Ranger Suarez — HP: Marvin Hudson

2026-04-26vs CLEBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Colin Holderman — HP: Ramon De Jesus

2026-04-26vs CLETop 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Tyler Rogers — HP: Ramon De Jesus

2026-04-26vs CLEBot 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Daulton Varsho vs Slade Cecconi — HP: Ramon De Jesus

2026-04-26vs CLETop 5ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Braydon Fisher — HP: Ramon De Jesus

2026-04-26vs CLEBot 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Slade Cecconi — HP: Ramon De Jesus

2026-04-25vs CLETop 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Louis Varland — HP: Quinn Wolcott

2026-04-25vs CLETop 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Louis Varland — HP: Quinn Wolcott

2026-04-25vs CLEBot 6ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Jesús Sánchez vs Matt Festa — HP: Quinn Wolcott

2026-04-25vs CLETop 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Angel Martínez vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Quinn Wolcott

2026-04-24vs CLEBot 9OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Cade Smith — HP: Paul Clemons

2026-04-24vs CLETop 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Mason Fluharty — HP: Paul Clemons

2026-04-24vs CLETop 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Mason Fluharty — HP: Paul Clemons

2026-04-24vs CLEBot 6ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Jesús Sánchez vs Gavin Williams — HP: Paul Clemons

2026-04-24vs CLEBot 5OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Gavin Williams — HP: Paul Clemons

2026-04-22vs LAATop 9ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Andrés Giménez vs Jordan Romano — HP: Chad Whitson

2026-04-22vs LAABot 7ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Braydon Fisher — HP: Chad Whitson

2026-04-22vs LAABot 5OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Eric Lauer — HP: Chad Whitson

2026-04-21vs LAABot 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Jeff Hoffman — HP: Chad Fairchild

2026-04-21vs LAABot 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Jeff Hoffman — HP: Chad Fairchild

2026-04-20vs LAATop 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kazuma Okamoto vs Reid Detmers — HP: Brian Walsh

2026-04-20vs LAABot 2OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Dylan Cease — HP: Brian Walsh

2026-04-20vs LAABot 1OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Dylan Cease — HP: Brian Walsh

2026-04-20vs LAATop 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Reid Detmers — HP: Brian Walsh

2026-04-19vs AZTop 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Myles Straw vs Andrew Hoffmann — HP: Roberto Ortiz

2026-04-19vs AZBot 2ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Nolan Arenado vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Roberto Ortiz

2026-04-19vs AZBot 2ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Kevin Gausman — HP: Roberto Ortiz

2026-04-18vs AZTop 6OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Andrés Giménez vs Zac Gallen — HP: Jim Wolf

2026-04-18vs AZBot 1OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Adrian Del Castillo vs Max Scherzer — HP: Jim Wolf

2026-04-16vs MILTop 9OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Angel Zerpa — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-04-16vs MILTop 8OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Trevor Megill — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-04-16vs MILBot 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Joe Mantiply — HP: Nestor Ceja

2026-04-15vs MILBot 4ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Dylan Cease — HP: Chris Guccione

2026-04-14vs MILBot 10ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Louis Varland — HP: David Rackley

2026-04-14vs MILTop 3ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Andrés Giménez vs Jacob Misiorowski — HP: David Rackley

2026-04-14vs MILBot 1ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Kevin Gausman — HP: David Rackley

2026-04-11vs MINBot 6OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Joe Ryan — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-04-11vs MINBot 4ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Davis Schneider vs Joe Ryan — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-04-11vs MINTop 3OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Eric Lauer — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-04-11vs MINTop 1OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Eric Lauer — HP: Tom Hanahan

2026-04-10vs MINTop 7ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Louis Varland — HP: Manny Gonzalez

2026-04-10vs MINBot 6OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Ernie Clement vs Anthony Banda — HP: Manny Gonzalez

2026-04-10vs MINBot 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

George Springer vs Simeon Woods Richardson — HP: Manny Gonzalez

2026-04-10vs MINBot 1ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Simeon Woods Richardson — HP: Manny Gonzalez

2026-04-08vs LADBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Andrés Giménez vs Ben Casparius — HP: Dan Bellino

2026-04-08vs LADBot 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Davis Schneider vs Jack Dreyer — HP: Dan Bellino

2026-04-07vs LADBot 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Kazuma Okamoto vs Yoshinobu Yamamoto — HP: Dan Merzel

2026-04-07vs LADTop 7OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Louis Varland — HP: Dan Merzel

2026-04-06vs LADBot 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Jesús Sánchez vs Will Klein — HP: Shane Livensparger

2026-04-06vs LADTop 6ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Tommy Nance — HP: Shane Livensparger

2026-04-06vs LADTop 4ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brandon Valenzuela vs Josh Fleming — HP: Shane Livensparger

2026-04-05vs CWSTop 9ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Ernie Clement vs Chris Murphy — HP: Jordan Baker

2026-04-04vs CWSBot 6OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Brandon Valenzuela vs Tommy Nance — HP: Junior Valentine

2026-04-03vs CWSBot 8ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Louis Varland — HP: Stu Scheurwater

2026-04-01vs COLTop 10ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Brendon Little — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-04-01vs COLBot 9ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Brett Sullivan vs Brennan Bernardino — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-04-01vs COLBot 9OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Jesús Sánchez vs Brennan Bernardino — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-04-01vs COLBot 8OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Ernie Clement vs Victor Vodnik — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-04-01vs COLBot 3OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Kyle Freeland — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-04-01vs COLBot 2ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Alejandro Kirk vs Kyle Freeland — HP: Brian O'Nora

2026-03-31vs COLBot 7ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Nathan Lukes vs Zach Agnos — HP: Laz Diaz

2026-03-31vs COLBot 5ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Kazuma Okamoto vs Jaden Hill — HP: Laz Diaz

2026-03-31vs COLTop 2ConfirmedCatcherBall → Ball

Tyler Heineman vs Max Scherzer — HP: Laz Diaz

2026-03-28vs ATHBot 7OverturnedBatterStrike → Ball

George Springer vs Elvis Alvarado — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-03-28vs ATHTop 6ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Brent Rooker vs Dylan Cease — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-03-28vs ATHTop 4OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Dylan Cease — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-03-28vs ATHBot 1ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs Jeffrey Springs — HP: Tripp Gibson

2026-03-30vs COLBot 8ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Andrés Giménez vs Chase Dollander — HP: Erich Bacchus

2026-03-30vs COLBot 6ConfirmedBatterStrike → Strike

Jesús Sánchez vs Chase Dollander — HP: Erich Bacchus

2026-03-29vs ATHTop 8OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Mason Fluharty — HP: Ryan Blakney

2026-03-27vs ATHTop 9OverturnedCatcherBall → Strike

Tyler Heineman vs Jeff Hoffman — HP: Marvin Hudson